The Catcher in the
Rye & Finding Forrester: Analyzing Allusions
The
Task:
The film, Finding Forrester, alludes to the quintessential bildungsroman, The Catcher in the Rye. The plot, the
characters, and the themes explored in the film are in many ways reflective of
and inspired by the novel, despite superficial differences (i.e. character
names, setting, etc.). In an analytical, expository essay, compare and contrast
Holden Caulfield with Jamal Wallace and William Forrester.
Here
is a list of things to explore in your essay:
- Hats
- Siblings/death
- Depression/guilt
- The role—or lack thereof—of parents
- Phoniness
- Elite, private schools
- Teachers
- Birds
Requirements:
- Typed; size 12 Times New Roman; double-spaced
- 2-3 pages in length (1 ½ does not count!)
- A minimum of 4 paragraphs
- It must contain insightful, clear analysis
- It must contain specific references to both the film and the book
The Catcher in the Rye & Finding Forrester: Analyzing Allusions [50
points]
Body
|
7
|
8
|
9
|
10
|
Intro
|
Whoa… What am I reading?
|
No quote or anecdote
|
May use a quote or anecdote
|
Uses an insightful anecdote or a quote to introduce the paper; clear
and concise
|
Analysis
|
Lack of analysis; indicates a lack of understanding regarding the
novel
|
Attempted analysis; few details
|
Some analysis; some details
|
Thoughtful analysis; use of specific details and support; indicates a
thorough understanding
|
Conclusion
|
Not included |
Attempted reiteration
|
Reiterates the main points of the paper
|
Insightful and clear reiteration
|
Nuts
and Bolts
|
2
|
3
|
4
|
5
|
Formatting
|
Did you read the paper? Handwritten, etc.
|
Issues with the formatting
|
Mostly properly formatted
|
Properly formatted
|
Grammar
|
Mistakes and errors abound
|
Mistakes
|
Obviously proofread
|
Immaculate
|
Length
|
Less than 2 pages
|
2 pages
|
2 ½ pages
|
3 pages
|
Timeliness
|
More than 2 days late
|
2 days late
|
1 day late
|
On time
|
Completed essays are to be posted in the comment section of this blog entry. Make sure to comment on the essays of your peers.